Around Our Table: Pa's Mac and Cheese

Therefore, since we are surrounded by so great a cloud of witnesses, let us also lay aside every weight and the sin that clings so closely, and let us run with perseverance the race that is set before us, looking to Jesus, the pioneer and perfecter of faith, who for the sake of the joy that was set before him endured the cross, disregarding its shame, and has taken his seat at the right hand of the throne of God.
—Hebrews 12:1–2

Another one of our non-negotiable Thanksgiving foods is macaroni and cheese, but not just any mac & cheese. This is Pa’s Mac & Cheese.

“Pa” is the familial name of my wife’s grandfather. It didn’t take long after Rachael and I began dating for me to realize that her grandparents were some of the most important people in her life. Very few memories of our early lives together don’t feature Granny and Pa in some way. We’d spend weekends at their lake house, fishing during the day and enjoying fish fries at night. My brother-in-law was young then and we'd spend afternoons together at his baseball games. They were around for every birthday, holiday, and other family event.

Though Pa often held onto the old-fashioned notion that cooking was a more feminine responsibility, every Thanksgiving and Christmas he would set himself up in the kitchen to make mac & cheese. It took years to get the recipe out of him, though I’m proud to say he let me in on the secret early on: “You take as much cheese as you think you might need, then you add more.”

It took his COPD getting particularly bad for him to finally give Rachael the recipe and relinquish his annual responsibilities to her. The first year she tried it, she forgot to add the egg that binds everything together, and Pa relished the proof that his place couldn’t easily be taken. The second year, I made the mistake of telling Rachael that her mac & cheese was every bit as good as Pa’s. He stared daggers at me across the table for the rest of Thanksgiving.

This Thanksgiving will mark our ninth since Pa’s been gone. But we’ll never see a Thanksgiving without his recipe on our table. It still bears his name. And every time we serve it, we have another reason to tell his stories.

A few weeks ago, on All Saints Sunday, we remembered those who have gone before us. Hebrews describes a “great cloud of witnesses” surrounding us as we run the race of faith. The chapter before this passage tells the stories of people who trusted God through uncertainty, hardship, and promises they would not live to see fulfilled. Their witness helps the next generation keep going.

We have people like that in our own lives: people whose love helped us understand God’s love, whose perseverance sustained us, whose example still gives us direction. Their lives continue to shape ours. We carry something of them into the ways we love, serve, welcome, and care for others.

That is part of what we confess when we speak of the communion of saints. In Christ, we belong to a community that stretches across generations, held together by a love that death cannot undo.

We miss Pa. I wish he could sit across from us again, even if it meant tempering my compliments of my wife's cooking. Keeping his recipe gives us a small, tangible way to honor someone whose life will forever be woven into ours.

As you gather this Thanksgiving, consider who helped make you who you are. Speak their names. Tell their stories. Give thanks for what you received through them—and consider how you will carry that goodness forward.

Pa’s Mac and Cheese

  1. Boil 1 cup of elbow macaroni in salted water until al dente, then drain.

  2. Shred 1 lb plus whatever you deem necessary (remember the secret recipe) of extra sharp cheddar. Pa always stuck to extra sharp, but he wasn’t your Pa, so go nuts. Throw in some Swiss and Gruyère and impress your family with how “continental” you are. Just don’t take a shortcut and use pre-shredded cheese. That stuff is coated to keep it from clumping, but it will also keep it from melting right. Pa would be disappointed.

  3. Pour 2 cans of evaporated milk into a bowl and whisk in 1 egg. Also whisk in some salt and pepper. How much? Last time I asked Pa, he just said, “until it's enough.” 

  4. Pour macaroni and cheese into an oven-safe dish, layering as much as possible. Pour the mil/egg mixture over top

  5. Bake at 375 for 30-45 minutes


Rev. Ryan Young

Next
Next

Around Our Table: Mom’s Sweet Potatoes